We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more›

All in One vs Single Function Printers

An all in one saves space and money, but one broken scanner can retire the whole machine. See when a single function printer is the better long-term buy.

An all in one printer prints, scans and copies in one box, while a single function printer only prints. All in ones save space and cost less than separate machines. Single function printers have fewer parts to fail and are often simpler and faster. Choose an all in one if you scan or copy regularly, and a single function printer if you mostly print.

What You Get With Each Type

An all in one printer, also called a multifunction printer, combines a print engine with a scanner, and often a copier and sometimes a fax. The scanner usually has a flatbed glass for single pages and books, and many models add an automatic document feeder for stacks of pages. You can scan to a computer, email or cloud storage, and copy without a computer.

A single function printer does one job. It receives a file from a computer, phone or network, and prints it. It has no glass, no feeder and no scanning software, so the body is smaller and the menus are simpler.

The question is whether you need the scanner and copier enough to accept the trade-offs. A home office that scans a receipt once a month has different needs from a small business that processes paper every day.

The Failure Mode Everyone Overlooks

In an all in one, the print engine and the scanner share one body, one power supply and one control board. When the scanner fails, you often cannot repair the unit economically, since service costs compare poorly with a replacement. You may be left with a printer that still prints but cannot scan, or a unit with an error code that blocks everything until it clears. A broken scanner can end the usefulness of the whole machine.

With a single function printer, the print engine stands alone. If you add a separate scanner, a failure in either one costs you only that part. You replace the scanner and keep the printer, or the reverse. Separate machines cost more in desk space, but the failure risk is separated.

This does not mean all in ones fail often. Many run for years. The point is that a scanner adds parts: glass, a moving carriage or sensor, a feeder with rollers and sometimes a lid hinge. Each is another place for wear. If you use the feeder heavily, the rollers wear out faster.

Common Weak Points in All-in-Ones

Look at these items before you buy, and ask how each is handled by the maker.

  • Feeder rollers: they pick up paper, and dust or wear can cause jams or multi page pickups. Check whether replacement roller kits exist.
  • Flatbed glass and sensor: streaks can appear if the glass gets dirty or scratched. Clean the glass gently, as the manual says.
  • Lid hinge: it can loosen when you scan thick books.
  • Network and software: scanning relies on drivers and apps that must be supported by your operating system.
  • Fax hardware: if you do not use it, it adds a part that never matters.

Read the manual for the maintenance schedule, and check how long the maker supports drivers. Our printers and scanners category lists models by type.

A print engine is the same technology in both types, so a laser engine in an all in one prints like a laser engine in a printer. Differences come from how the maker designs each model. Single function printers sometimes put the money into a faster engine, a larger paper tray or a bigger toner cartridge, since they do not pay for a scanner. All in one models at the same price may have a slower or smaller engine.

Check these values on the product page.

  • Pages per minute for printing, and the time to the first page.
  • Paper tray size and the maximum duty cycle, if listed.
  • Print resolution and whether it suits your documents.
  • Duplex printing, which prints on both sides automatically.
  • Scan speed and whether the feeder scans both sides in one pass.

If you print a lot of pages, the engine details matter more than the scanner. If you scan stacks of paper, the feeder speed and two sided scanning matter.

Cost and Space

An all in one usually costs less than a printer plus a separate scanner. It also takes one desk space and one power outlet. That is the main reason people choose it.

Consumables cost the same either way, since the ink or toner is tied to the print engine. When you compare, count the ink or toner cost per page, not just the price of the machine. A cheaper machine with expensive cartridges costs more over time.

Think about the second and third purchase too. If the scanner dies and you replace the machine, you pay for a new print engine you did not need. With separate machines, you replace only the failed one. For one or two scans a month, a phone scanning app can fill the gap, and a single function printer plus a phone costs the least.

Matching the Choice to Your Work

  • You scan and copy often: an all in one with a feeder.
  • You scan a few pages occasionally: an all in one without a feeder, or a phone scanning app plus a single function printer.
  • You print a lot and rarely scan: a single function printer with a large tray.
  • You need reliable scanning of stacks: a separate document scanner, which handles paper better than an all in one feeder.
  • You have limited space: an all in one.

Questions to Ask Before You Buy

  • Which functions will I actually use every week?
  • How many pages per month do I print and scan?
  • Does the maker supply replacement parts or service for the scanner?
  • Do I need duplex scanning and a feeder?
  • What will the ink or toner cost per page be?
  • If the scanner fails, will I still be able to print?

A written answer to these questions points to the right type faster than any list of features. Keep the answers with your shopping notes.

Who Should Choose Which

Choose an all in one if you want one box for a home office, a student room or a small shop, and you scan or copy regularly. Choose a single function printer if you print many pages, want the simplest machine or want to separate failure risks. Pair it with a phone app or a separate scanner when you need to scan.

See our best printer roundup for models, and read the how we review page for the way we weigh specifications.

A Worked Example

A freelancer prints invoices a few times a week and scans signed contracts once or twice a month. An all in one with a flatbed meets that need, saves a desk, and the freelancer accepts that a scanner failure may mean a replacement. A small clinic prints hundreds of pages a day and scans stacks of forms. A single function printer with a large tray handles the volume, and a separate document scanner handles the stacks, so the failure of one does not stop the other.

What to Do Before Replacing a Failed Unit

If the scanner stops working, check for a paper jam, a stuck carriage lock switch, a loose cable and driver problems. Restart the machine and the computer, update the software and follow the manual’s reset steps. If the unit shows a scanner error after these checks, ask the maker or a service center for a repair estimate, and compare it with the cost of a replacement. Do not open the case beyond what the manual allows, since power supplies and lasers can be hazardous.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an all in one printer worth it for home use?

For most homes, yes. It saves space, costs less than separate machines and handles occasional scanning and copying. The trade-off is that a broken scanner can end the usefulness of the whole unit. If you scan rarely, a single function printer and a phone app also work well.

What happens if the scanner on my all in one breaks?

Sometimes the printer still prints and only scanning stops. In other cases an error blocks the whole unit. Repair costs often compare poorly with replacing a low priced machine, so ask for an estimate. A separate scanner and printer keep a failure from affecting both.

Do single function printers last longer?

Often, since they have fewer parts. A print engine without a scanner has no feeder rollers, glass or scanning sensor to wear out. Lifespan still depends on use, maintenance and the model. Check the maker’s duty cycle and parts support.

Do I need a feeder on an all in one?

Only if you scan stacks of pages. A feeder speeds up multi page scans, though the rollers can wear out or jam. For occasional single pages, a flatbed alone is enough. For heavy scanning, a separate document scanner works better.

Final Thoughts

Pick an all in one for space and convenience if you scan and copy regularly, and accept that one failed part can end the unit. Pick a single function printer for simplicity and heavy printing, and add a scanner or phone app. Match the choice to your weekly tasks and think about what happens when something breaks.

Related buying guides

About the author

BuyOnceChoice Editorial Team
BuyOnceChoice Editorial Team

The BuyOnceChoice Editorial Team researches durable products worth buying once. Our guides compare published specifications, warranty terms, expert review consensus, and verified owner feedback. We do not conduct our own product trials. See How We Review and our Editorial Policy for our standards.