Propane vs Natural Gas Grill: Cost, Heat, Conversion
Compare fuel cost math, heat output, portability and conversion kit limits, and learn why a licensed installer should handle any gas line work.
Propane versus natural gas for a grill comes down to portability and heat density against a continuous fuel supply and lower fuel cost. Propane is stored in a tank and carries more energy per cubic foot, while natural gas comes from a house line and never runs out mid cook. Heat quality is similar when a grill is built for its fuel, and converting from one to the other depends on a manufacturer approved kit.
How the Two Fuels Differ
Propane is liquefied under pressure and sold in tanks. It contains roughly 2,500 BTU per cubic foot of vapor and about 91,500 BTU per gallon. Natural gas is delivered through pipes and contains roughly 1,000 BTU per cubic foot, so a natural gas grill needs larger orifices to deliver the same heat. Natural gas also runs at much lower pressure, which is why a grill’s regulator and orifices are fuel specific.
Because of these differences, a grill is built or converted for one fuel. You cannot connect a propane grill to a natural gas line, or the reverse, by swapping a hose. The wrong fuel can cause weak flames or dangerous overheating.
Cost per Cook
Propane cost depends on tank exchange or refill price. A 20 pound tank holds about 430,000 BTU. A grill at 30,000 to 40,000 BTU per hour on high burns through a tank in roughly 10 to 14 hours, and most cooks run burners lower, so a tank often lasts for many sessions.
Natural gas is usually cheaper per BTU than propane, but the price is set by your gas bill, and the amount used for grilling is small. To estimate: multiply the grill’s BTU per hour by hours of cooking, then divide by about 100,000 BTU per therm. Multiply by your utility’s price per therm. For occasional grillers the savings are modest, and the installation cost of a gas line can outweigh them for years.
Heat Output and Performance
BTU ratings of the same grill model in each fuel are usually similar, and a well designed grill sears and holds temperature equally well on either. The difference people notice is consistency. A tank can fall in pressure when nearly empty or very cold, while natural gas delivers steady pressure. Propane can be slightly hotter at low settings on some models, though this varies and the manual is the best guide.
Preheat time, searing and even heat depend more on the burners, lid fit and cooking grates than on the fuel.
Portability and Convenience
Propane gives you freedom. Move the grill, take it camping or tailgating, or place it anywhere on the patio. The cost is refills and the occasional empty tank at a bad moment, which a gauge or spare tank solves. Natural gas ties the grill to a line, usually through a quick disconnect hose in a fixed spot. In return you never refill, never haul tanks and never run out.
Conversion Kits and Their Limits
Some grills offer a manufacturer conversion kit that swaps orifices and the regulator. Rules to remember:
- Use only the kit listed for your exact grill model and fuel direction.
- A kit for a different model, or a generic part, is not safe even if it fits.
- Some grills are sold for one fuel only and have no approved kit.
- Converting may affect warranty or listing, so read the manual first.
- After any conversion, check every connection for leaks with soapy water before use.
Never drill out orifices or modify fittings yourself. If the manual does not describe a conversion, treat the grill as fixed to its fuel.
Installation and Safety
A natural gas connection needs a shutoff valve, correct pipe size and leak checks, and in many areas a permit and a licensed plumber or gas fitter. Do not attempt the line yourself. Propane grills need a hose and regulator in good condition, a tank kept upright outdoors and a regular leak check. Keep either type away from walls, overhangs and combustibles by the clearances in the manual, and never use a grill indoors or in a garage.
Who Should Choose Which
- Renters, small patios, tailgaters: propane.
- Fixed outdoor kitchen near a house gas line: natural gas.
- Heavy year round users who hate refills: natural gas.
- Light users who move the grill: propane.
Browse the grills and smokers category, the best grill roundup and How We Review for choices.
Running the Numbers for Your Own Grill
Here is a method you can follow with your own figures. Step one: find the grill’s total BTU per hour, which is usually the sum of the main burners. Step two: estimate cooking hours per month. Step three: multiply to get monthly BTU. Step four: divide by the energy in your fuel to find the quantity used. For propane, divide by about 91,500 BTU per gallon. For natural gas, divide by roughly 100,000 BTU per therm or about 1,000 BTU per cubic foot.
Example: a grill rated at 36,000 BTU per hour that runs on high for 20 hours in a month would use about 720,000 BTU if every burner stayed at maximum. On propane that is around 8 gallons, a little under two tanks. On natural gas that is about 7 therms, which most utility bills show as a small line item. Real use is lower because most cooks hold burners at medium.
Compare the result with the installation cost of a gas line, which is a one time expense, and with your refill habits. If you grill a few times a month, the fuel cost difference is small either way, and the decision should rest on convenience. If you grill several times a week all year and the grill sits within reach of a house gas line, the continuous supply can be worth it.
Common Mistakes With Fuel Choices
- Assuming a natural gas hose can be hooked to a propane grill. The orifices and regulator are different and the result can be unsafe.
- Buying a grill sold for one fuel on the hope that a kit exists. Confirm in the manual or product page first.
- Letting the tank run low in cold weather and blaming the grill for weak heat.
- Skipping the leak check after any change, tank swap or long storage. A brush of soapy water takes a minute.
- Storing a spare tank indoors, in a garage or near heat. Tanks belong upright, outdoors and shaded.
- Running a gas line without a shutoff valve, or hiring someone who does not pull a permit where one is required.
What to Check Before You Buy
Look at the grill’s data plate or listing for the fuel type and the rated BTU. Check whether the maker sells a conversion kit and what it costs. Confirm hose length, quick disconnect type and whether a natural gas hose is included. Look at burner material and warranty, since stainless burners and a long burner warranty reduce replacement parts over time. For built in grills, confirm the cutout dimensions and the clearances for combustible surfaces in the island. If you plan to keep the grill on a deck, check the local rules about propane and decks, since some buildings restrict tank storage.
Weather, Altitude and Seasonal Use
Cold weather affects propane tanks more than a natural gas line. As a tank empties and the temperature falls, vapor pressure drops, which can leave a grill with low flames at the end of a winter cook. Keeping a spare tank and storing it outdoors in the shade, not in a heated space, avoids the problem. Natural gas pressure comes from the utility and stays steady, which is one reason year round grillers favor it.
Altitude and appliance design can also matter. Burner orifices are sized for a fuel and for typical conditions, and manufacturers sometimes list limits or adjustments for high elevation in the manual. If you live well above sea level, read the manual rather than adjusting parts yourself. A grill that burns yellow, pops, or lights with a loud whoosh needs attention, so stop, shut off the gas and follow the troubleshooting steps or call the maker.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is natural gas cheaper than propane for grilling?
Usually per BTU, yes, but grilling uses little fuel, so savings are modest. A gas line installation can cost more than years of propane refills for a casual user. Check your utility rate and the grill’s BTU rating to compare for your own use.
Can I convert my propane grill to natural gas?
Only if the manufacturer offers a kit for your exact model. The kit changes orifices and the regulator, and you should leak check afterward. Do not drill orifices or use a generic part, because the wrong setup can cause weak flames or unsafe overheating.
Does natural gas make a grill hotter?
No, not by itself. A grill built for either fuel is sized to deliver a similar BTU rating, so heat is comparable. Natural gas provides steadier pressure, while propane pressure can drop in cold weather or when the tank is nearly empty.
Do I need a professional to install a natural gas line?
In most areas, yes. Gas connections usually require a licensed plumber or gas fitter and a permit in many places. They will size the pipe, add a shutoff valve and check for leaks, which are not steps to attempt yourself.
Final Thoughts
Choose propane if you want a movable grill and low upfront cost, and natural gas if the grill stays put near a line and you value never refilling. Use only manufacturer approved conversion parts, leak check every connection and hire a licensed professional for the gas line.
Related buying guides
- Built In vs Freestanding Grill: Planning and Clearances
- Flat Top Griddle vs Grill: What Each Cooks Best
- Gas Grill Leak Check and Propane Safety Basics