We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more›

Propane vs Electric vs Infrared Patio Heater

Compare heat coverage, running cost, wind tolerance, covered patio rules and electrical needs to pick between a propane heater and an electric infrared model.

Propane versus electric patio heaters is a choice between portable, high output flame heat and plug-in, lower output radiant heat, and infrared is mostly a way of delivering electric or gas heat rather than a third fuel. Propane suits open patios and large groups, electric infrared suits covered or small spaces with an outlet, and the right pick depends on wind, ceiling, power and how many people you want to warm.

How Each Type Heats

A propane patio heater burns gas in a burner under a reflector or inside a flame tube. A typical standing model is rated around 40,000 BTU per hour and heats mostly by warming the air around the head and by radiating some heat downward. Because the air rises, much of the warmth is lost overhead and to wind, so people sit close and below the head.

An electric heater converts power into heat with an element, usually a quartz or carbon tube. A standard 120 volt plug-in model is commonly rated at 1,500 watts, which equals about 5,100 BTU per hour. Hardwired models on 240 volt circuits can go higher. Electric heaters usually radiate in a focused beam, so they warm people and objects directly rather than the air.

Infrared describes the way heat travels. Infrared heaters, whether electric or gas, emit radiant energy that warms what it strikes, such as your clothes and skin, with less dependence on still air. That is why infrared works better in a breeze than a convection style heater of the same rating. Some propane heaters are also infrared, with a ceramic or metal burner face that glows.

Heat Coverage and Performance

Propane heaters at 40,000 BTU can take the edge off a cool evening for a table of four to six people within a few feet of the head, depending on temperature and wind. They are the usual choice for open patios and restaurant style layouts because they need no outlet and produce high output.

A 1,500 watt electric infrared heater is gentler. Mounted overhead or on a wall at the height and distance the manual specifies, it warms a small seating area of two to four people. It does not warm the air in an open yard. In a covered or partly enclosed porch, it can feel comfortable, because the structure holds some of the radiant heat.

Compare heaters by where the heat lands rather than by raw rating. Ask three questions before buying: how far is the nearest person from the heater, how high is the ceiling or mount, and does the wind reach the seating area. A high rated heater far from guests warms less than a lower rated heater placed close.

Running Cost

Propane cost depends on your tank refill price, so use your own figures. A 20 pound tank holds roughly 430,000 BTU, so a 40,000 BTU heater at full output burns about one tank in 10 hours. Divide your cost per refill by 10 for an hourly estimate at maximum setting.

Electric cost is easier. A 1,500 watt heater uses 1.5 kilowatt hours per hour of full operation. Multiply by your utility rate per kilowatt hour for an hourly estimate. Because electric output is low, many people run it for the whole evening, and the cost per hour is often modest, but compare per person warmed rather than per hour alone.

Wind, Weather and Covered Spaces

Wind is the biggest enemy of convection style propane heaters. Infrared electric heaters handle breezes better, though they still lose effect in strong wind or rain. Check the rating on any heater for wet locations, and look for a listed outdoor rating on electric models.

Covered spaces change the rules. Propane heaters need open air and large clearances overhead. Do not place a freestanding propane heater under a covered porch or low ceiling unless the manual specifically allows it, and never in an enclosed or screened room, because combustion produces carbon monoxide. Electric infrared heaters designed for covered patios are usually the safer way to heat a porch.

Electrical and Gas Requirements

Propane heaters need a tank of the size the manual specifies, a regulator and hose that match, and a level, stable base. Use only listed parts. Electric plug-in heaters need an outlet and a circuit that can carry the load. A 1,500 watt heater is typically used on its own circuit and should not share it with other high draw devices. Extension cords can overheat, so check what the manual allows. Hardwired electric heaters, wall mounted units and anything on a 240 volt circuit need a licensed electrician and may need a permit.

Upkeep and Durability

Propane heaters need periodic hose and regulator inspection, leak checks with soapy water, a clean burner and a cover in the off season. Piezo igniters wear out and can be replaced. Electric heaters have fewer parts: keep the housing clean, check the cord and plug, and replace the element if it stops glowing. Neither type likes long exposure to rain without a cover, and powder coated steel finishes eventually show rust at scratches.

Who Should Choose Which

  • Open patio, groups of four or more: propane, placed close to seating.
  • Covered porch with an outlet: electric infrared, ideally mounted per the manual.
  • Windy site: infrared of either fuel, positioned to shield from the breeze.
  • Renters or occasional use: freestanding propane or a plug-in electric you can move.
  • Permanent seating with no floor space: a wall or ceiling mounted electric model. See the wall mounted outdoor heater roundup.

You can browse more in the outdoor heaters category and learn how products are chosen at How We Review.

Sizing Your Choice With Worked Examples

Example one: a 10 by 12 foot open patio with four chairs, no roof, and a breeze most evenings. A propane heater near 40,000 BTU placed within a few feet of the seats is the practical choice, because a 1,500 watt electric unit has too little output for open air. Add a windbreak panel or position the heater upwind and you get more comfort from the same fuel.

Example two: a screened or roofed porch of about 8 by 10 feet with an outdoor rated outlet. A wall or ceiling mounted electric infrared heater at the height listed in the manual warms two or three people directly. A propane heater here would be a safety problem, because the roof traps exhaust and the manual will forbid it.

Example three: a restaurant style setup or large gathering. One heater will not warm eight people. Plan one propane heater per table of four to six, spaced so no one sits more than a few feet from a head, or use several electric heaters on separate circuits, each wired by an electrician.

Common Buyer Regrets

  • Buying by BTU alone and finding that the heat blew away. Check reflector design and plan seating close to the head.
  • Choosing a plug-in electric heater for a large open yard, where its output is simply too small.
  • Putting a heater on a shared circuit that trips when a blender or string lights run at the same time.
  • Underestimating tank handling. A full 20 pound tank weighs around 37 pounds, and a tall heater with a base tank needs a stable, level spot.
  • Ignoring storage. Both types last longer under a cover, and a propane tank must never be stored inside the house.
  • Skipping the clearance rules. Keep the distances the manual lists from walls, umbrellas, awnings, trees and hanging lights, and never leave a heater running unattended.

Checks to Make on the Product Page

Before buying, look for these details instead of relying on marketing language. For propane: the stated BTU range, the tank size it uses, whether the tank is hidden in the base, the tip-over shutoff and the ignition type. For electric: the wattage, the voltage, the plug type or hardwire requirement, the wet location or outdoor rating and the recommended mounting height and angle. For both: a safety listing mark from a recognized standards organization, the clearance diagram and the warranty terms. If any of these are missing from the listing, check the manual before purchase.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an electric patio heater cheaper to run than propane?

Often, for small spaces, yes, because a 1,500 watt heater uses 1.5 kilowatt hours per hour. A 40,000 BTU propane heater burns a 20 pound tank in about 10 hours. Compare using your own electricity rate and tank refill cost, and remember propane warms a larger area.

Can I use a propane patio heater under a covered porch?

Only if the manual explicitly allows it, and most do not. Propane heaters need open air and overhead clearance because they produce carbon monoxide and hot exhaust. For covered porches, an electric infrared heater designed for that space is the usual safer option.

Does infrared heat work in wind?

Better than convection heaters, because infrared warms people and objects directly rather than the air. It still loses effect in strong wind, so place the heater close to seating and use windbreaks. Check the manual for the recommended mounting height and distance.

How many BTU do I need for a patio?

Most standing propane heaters sit near 40,000 BTU, enough for a small group in a sheltered spot. Open areas need more output or closer seating. Because BTU measures fuel input, also consider wind, ceiling height and distance from the heater.

Final Thoughts

Choose propane for open patios and larger groups, and electric infrared for covered, small or windy spaces with a reliable outlet. Follow clearance rules in the manual, never use propane in an enclosed area, and use a licensed electrician for any hardwired installation.

Related buying guides

About the author

BuyOnceChoice Editorial Team
BuyOnceChoice Editorial Team

The BuyOnceChoice Editorial Team researches durable products worth buying once. Our guides compare published specifications, warranty terms, expert review consensus, and verified owner feedback. We do not conduct our own product trials. See How We Review and our Editorial Policy for our standards.